menu

The Magic is in the Challenges

BY FRASER CAIN | 1 min read

I’m sure the entire HeroX team has had this same thought process. What we’re enabling is pretty straightforward. It’s a proven concept demonstrated by the Longitude Prize (1714), the Orteig Prize (won by Charles Lindbergh in 1927), and more recently, the Ansari XPrize.

Offer up a prize and let the world compete to win it. You only pay when the thing actually exists.

The XPrize was only awarded when an actual spaceship was created with the ability to reach the edge of space.

No spaceship, no prize.

And so, as we attempt to extend this concept into the modern internet age, it seems straightforward on its surface:

- Anyone can create a challenge.
- Anyone can pledge to help fund the prize.
- Anyone can compete to solve the challenge and win the price.

In theory, you should be able to generate an ecosystem, a positive feedback loop that generates challenges, raises funds, and fixes the world’s problems.

And yet, it’s like a Gordian Knot to untangle.

In order to be willing to compete in a challenge, the competitors will need to have confidence that the challenge is winnable – that it’s worth taking on, and that the prize is worth going after.

So, in order to fund the prize, a large group of people will need to be inspired by the promise of the challenge.

And so, everything really rests on the quality of the challenge.

Create an amazing challenge idea, and it’ll spread virally across the internet, gaining momentum and funding. Competitors will show up and compete to win the prize.

If someone does win the prize, well, that makes the world a better place.

A disease gets cured, or carbon dioxide gets sequestered, or data is crunched more efficiently.

And it was only possible because someone figured out a fantastic challenge. In just a few short sentences, they clarified the obstacles and inspired an army to come together and fix a problem.

But knowing which sentences to write, that’s the tough part.

Some day, I hope, we’ll all be able to see the world in challenges, and know exactly how to describe the problem to get people to help solve it.

Until then, I’ll be working away in the corner, trying to untie this Gordian Knot. I’d love to get your help.

more like this
comments
Engineering
Michigan's Dual-Use Innovation Strategy: Why the Future of Aerospace Depends on Crowdsourced Agility
In a recent HeroX Speaker Series conversation, Mark Ignash pulls back the curtain on how Michigan, where defense is the state's third-largest industry, is reimagining what's possible when you combine industrial strength, academic talent, and agile public-private partnerships.
3 min read
Education
Beyond the VC Bubble: Dr. Robert Nason on the Plurality of Entrepreneurship
We sit down with Dr. Robert Nason, Director of Innovation and Entrepreneurship at McGill University. He challenges the "dominant prototype" of entrepreneurship and explores how leaders can "design for serendipity" to foster interdisciplinary breakthroughs and mindset shifts across any organization.
4 min read
Arts & Design
When Creativity Meets Entrepreneurship: Annalyce D'Agostino-Gavin on Unlocking Untapped Potential
What happens when an analytical mind meets a creative spirit? For Annalyce D'Agostino-Gavin, Creative Development and Innovation Strategist at Montclair State University's Feliciano Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation, it sparked a journey that's changing what it means to be an entrepreneur.
3 min read